Traveling from New York to explore two very different parts of Pennsylvania is a tempting idea, and this day trip to Philadelphia and Amish Country aims to deliver just that. Offered by Amadeo Travel, it promises a full 14-hour adventure packed with history, culture, and scenic countryside. With an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 from over 700 reviews, it’s clear this tour resonates with many travelers, but like all experiences, it’s worth weighing the pros and cons before booking.
What we particularly like about this trip is how it combines iconic American landmarks with an authentic glimpse into Amish life. The tour guides seem to be a highlight themselves—many reviews praise their knowledge, friendliness, and humor. Another plus: the value for money feels reasonable given the comprehensive itinerary and included activities. That said, some travelers find the schedule a bit rushed, especially at the Amish stop, which might not satisfy those wanting a slow, immersive experience.
This tour suits history buffs, culture seekers, and anyone keen to see contrasting sides of Pennsylvania in one go. If you’re okay with an early start and a full day on the road, this trip offers a wonderful way to make the most of your time.
- Key Points
- A Complete Breakdown of the Tour Journey
- Departure and Travel Time from New York
- Exploring Philadelphia: City Highlights
- The Amish Country: Countryside and Culture
- What’s Included and What’s Not
- Considerations on Value
- The Review from Travelers
- Who Will Love This Trip?
- Final Thoughts
- FAQ
- Our Top Picks in New York City
- More 1-Day Tours in New York City
- More Tour Reviews in New York City
- Not for you? Here's more things to do in New York City we have recnetly reviewed
Key Points
- Diverse itinerary combines Philadelphia’s landmarks with Amish countryside
- Guides are consistently praised for their knowledge and friendliness
- Transportation is in a comfortable, air-conditioned bus, though some reviews mention narrow steps and limited legroom
- Amish experience includes a buggy ride and market visit, offering a taste of rural life
- Price point at $149 offers good value considering the guided tour, transportation, and activities
- Timing can be tight; some reviews note feeling rushed, especially at certain stops
👉 Check out our guide to the 3 Best Craft Beer Tours And Tastings In New York City
A Complete Breakdown of the Tour Journey
Here are more great tours and experiences we've reviewed in New York City
Departure and Travel Time from New York
Starting bright and early at 6:30 AM outside the Port Authority bus terminal, this tour is a serious commitment for early risers. The bus departs from a centrally located spot, making it convenient if you’re staying in Manhattan. Expect a roughly 3-hour drive through New Jersey, giving you a chance to partially relax or watch the scenery roll by.
While most travelers find the air-conditioned bus comfortable, a few mention that the narrow steps and limited legroom on the van can be less ideal for taller or mobility-challenged guests. The bus is equipped with chargers and Wi-Fi, which helps pass the time.
Exploring Philadelphia: City Highlights
Once in Philadelphia, the guide takes you on a walking tour that covers some of the city’s most iconic sites. You’ll see Elfert Alley, the oldest inhabited street in America, which offers a tangible connection to colonial Philadelphia. Of course, the Liberty Bell is a must-see—many visitors are inspired by its symbolism of American independence.
Constitution Hall and Independence Square provide context for the nation’s founding, with some guides offering detailed explanations about their significance. A crowd favorite is running up the “Rocky Steps” at the Philadelphia Museum of Art, which lets you channel your inner boxer and enjoy fantastic views of the city skyline.
Reviewers mention that the guided commentary makes these sights come alive. One noted, “Our guide was very informative,” and many appreciate the mix of facts and humor that keeps the group engaged. You’ll likely spend about 2-3 hours in the city, with some free time for photos or quick shopping.
The Amish Country: Countryside and Culture
After a city morning, the tour heads west to Lancaster County to experience Amish life firsthand. As you drive through lush farmland, you’ll see the scenic beauty of Amish country—a stark contrast to the city bustle. Many reviewers describe this part as “peaceful” and “scenic”, with a special highlight being the authentic Amish buggy ride.
The buggy ride is a genuine opportunity to learn about Amish traditions—no electricity, no telephones, no modern appliances—and how their communities sustain themselves without modern technology. One traveler called it “an eye-opener,” and others appreciated the chance to see Amish farms and animals up close.
You’ll also visit an Amish market where local products are sold, including homemade foods and handcrafted items. Many guests rave about the delicious country cooking for lunch, and some mention Amish ice cream as a standout treat. The market visit allows for browsing at your own pace, though some reviews note that the time spent at the Amish stop can feel rushed, with only about an hour and a half allocated.
More Great Tours NearbyWhat’s Included and What’s Not
The tour covers round-trip transportation in an air-conditioned bus, along with a professional guide who speaks your preferred language—including options like English, French, German, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Hebrew, and Japanese. The guide’s role is crucial, and many reviews highlight how knowledgeable and friendly guides elevate the experience.
The Amish buggy ride and market visit are part of the package, offering a genuine Amish experience. However, meals are not included, so plan to bring snacks or purchase food during the stops.
Considerations on Value
At $149 per person, this tour offers solid value, considering the extensive sightseeing, transportation, and guided commentary. For those wanting a cost-effective way to see both Philadelphia and Amish Country in one day, it’s a good option. Some reviews, however, point out that the schedule can be quite tight, especially at the Amish stop, which could be a downside for travelers preferring more leisurely exploration.
The Review from Travelers
From enthusiastic praise to constructive criticism, reviews paint a balanced picture. Many travelers loved the knowledgeable guides, with comments like, “Carlo was an excellent guide,” and “Iris provided non-stop information.” The scenic Amish countryside and authentic buggy ride frequently emerge as the trip’s highlights, with many saying it’s “a must-do” for a taste of rural Pennsylvania.
On the flip side, some mention feeling rushed, especially at the Amish market and during city sightseeing. One reviewer noted, “The Amish farm tour was interesting, but it was a bit rushed.” Others criticize the transportation for narrow steps and limited space, which could be uncomfortable for some.
Despite these minor issues, the overall sentiment is positive, with many stating they would recommend the tour for its informative nature and overall experience.
Who Will Love This Trip?
This day trip is best suited for travelers who enjoy a busy, well-organized schedule and want to see a lot in one day. History buffs will appreciate the Philadelphia landmarks and the guided insights, while those curious about Amish culture will find the buggy ride and market visit illuminating. It’s especially attractive for visitors who want to maximize their day without sacrificing guided commentary.
If you’re looking for a laid-back, immersive Amish experience with outside farm visits or staying longer in Philadelphia, you might find this trip somewhat rushed. However, if your goal is a rundown with authentic touches, you’ll likely be very satisfied.
Final Thoughts
This From NYC day trip to Philadelphia and Amish Country offers a balanced mix of city history and rural tradition at a accessible price point. The guides’ expertise and friendly demeanor consistently stand out, making the experience enjoyable and educational. The scenic drives and photo opportunities are plentiful, and the Amish activities provide a rare glimpse into a lifestyle unchanged for generations.
While the schedule can feel tight—particularly at the Amish stop—the overall experience is engaging and worthwhile. It’s perfect for history lovers, cultural explorers, and those wanting to squeeze the most out of a single day. Just bring comfortable shoes, an open mind, and a sense of adventure.
From NYC: Day Trip to Philadelphia and Amish Country
“Not bad. But time spend in Philadelphia too little. The time spend at the farm too much.”
FAQ
How early does the tour start?
The tour departs at 6:30 AM from outside the Port Authority bus terminal on 42nd Street, so expect an early morning start.
What is included in the price?
Your ticket covers round-trip transportation, a guided tour in your preferred language, sightseeing in Philadelphia, an authentic Amish buggy ride, and a visit to an Amish market.
Are meals included?
No, meals are not provided. You’ll want to bring snacks or plan to purchase food during stops, especially at the Amish market where country cooking is available.
How long is the Amish buggy ride?
The exact duration isn’t specified, but the visit to the Amish market is about one and a half hours total. The buggy ride itself is described as “authentic,” offering a chance to see Amish life firsthand.
Is the tour suitable for children?
Yes, all ages are allowed, but infants should be in a backpack or chest carrier. Comfortable walking shoes are strongly recommended, as there’s some walking involved.
What if I have mobility issues?
Some reviews mention narrow bus steps and limited legroom, which could pose challenges. Check with the tour provider if you have specific mobility needs.
How long does the entire trip last?
The trip lasts around 14 hours, usually starting early in the morning and returning by evening.
Can I cancel if my plans change?
Yes, you can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.
Is there a language guide option?
Yes, guides are available in English, French, German, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Hebrew, and Japanese.
Would I recommend this tour?
If you’re looking for a comprehensive, guided experience that balances city sights with countryside charm, yes. Just be prepared for a full, sometimes hurried, but rewarding day.
In essence, this tour offers a lively, educational, and scenic way to see some of the best of Pennsylvania in one day. Whether you’re a history enthusiast or simply curious about Amish life, it’s a good value for an all-in-one adventure.
You can check availability for your dates here:
