Fresh seafood and local flavors define lunch on New Providence Island. The Fish Fry area at Arawak Cay serves up the island’s best conch fritters and rock lobster at wallet-friendly prices. My favorite stops include the waterfront tables at Potter’s Cay, where fishermen deliver catches directly to local kitchens.
For a memorable upscale experience, the historic Graycliff Restaurant offers exceptional service and an impressive wine cellar, while The Poop Deck combines harbor views with perfectly prepared local fish.
The lunchtime food tours really shine here. I especially love the sunset cruise-and-dine experiences – they combine sailing, storytelling, and authentic Bahamian cooking. The farm-to-table tours showcase local ingredients while supporting island farmers.
Check out these top food experiences on New Providence Island:
Key Points
-
Arawak Cay offers a vibrant seafood shack atmosphere and a variety of local dishes, including conch fritters and Bahamian peas ‘n’ rice.
-
The Fish Fry at Potter’s Cay provides a diverse selection of freshly caught fish, served alongside traditional sides and Bahamian cocktails.
-
Graycliff Restaurant provides an upscale dining experience with an extensive wine list, showcasing both international and Bahamian culinary influences.
-
The Poop Deck seafood restaurant is known for its waterfront views and specialties like rock lobster, grilled or steamed.
-
Café Matisse combines Italian and Bahamian flavors, offering a range of pasta dishes and delectable desserts in a charming setting.
Bahamas Adventure: Pigs, Reef, Turtles, and Beach With Lunch
Embarking on the Bahamas Adventure: Pigs, Reef, Turtles, and Beach with Lunch tour, guests can expect a day filled with diverse experiences.
This highly-rated excursion takes travelers to New Providence Island, where they’ll encounter friendly pigs, explore vibrant coral reefs, and relax on the beach.
With a maximum of 20 participants, the tour provides ample opportunities for personalized attention. Included amenities such as snorkeling gear, paddleboards, and kayaks allow guests to fully enjoy the Bahamian landscape.
Though some reviews raise concerns about animal welfare, the tour generally receives positive feedback for its friendly staff, quality equipment, and enjoyable activities.
Read our full review: Bahamas Adventure: Pigs, Reef, Turtles, and Beach With Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Nassau Aquatic Reef Tour: Snorkel, Turtle Watch, Lunch Included
The Nassau Aquatic Reef Tour offers a comprehensive experience for those seeking to enjoy the natural wonders of the Bahamian islands.
The tour visits Pearl Island, Green Turtle Cay, and Rose Island, allowing participants to observe marine life like sea turtles, stingrays, and tropical fish. The small group size ensures more attention from the knowledgeable guide.
Included in the $185 per person price are bottled water, rum punch, light snacks, and a full lunch. All necessary snorkeling gear is provided, and pick-up and drop-off service at Jimmy Buffett’s Margaritaville Bahamas is available.
While some guests have reported mixed experiences with communication and organization, the tour generally receives positive reviews for its friendly guides and memorable encounters with the local wildlife.
Read our full review: Nassau Aquatic Reef Tour: Snorkel, Turtle Watch, Lunch Included Review
Book now: Check availability
Exuma Island Hopping & Swimming Pigs Tour With Lunch From Nassau
For those seeking a unique and unforgettable island adventure, the Exuma Island Hopping & Swimming Pigs Tour from Nassau delivers an exceptional experience. Boasting a 92% recommendation rate, the tour takes visitors to multiple islands, including opportunities to swim with nurse sharks and pigs, snorkel around a rumored Pablo Escobar plane wreck, and explore the scenic beauty of the Exumas.
With lunch, snacks, and beverages included, the tour provides a well-rounded day. Though not wheelchair accessible and requiring a moderate fitness level, the tour receives high praise for its attentive crew, well-organized itinerary, and memorable moments.
Flexibility in booking and cancellation policies add to the appeal of this popular tour.
Read our full review: Exuma Island Hopping & Swimming Pigs Tour With Lunch From Nassau Review
Book now: Check availability
Suncay Swimming Pigs Adventure With Lunch at Pigs Beach
The SunCay Swimming Pigs Adventure with Lunch at Pigs Beach offers visitors a unique opportunity to interact with the famous swimming pigs of the Bahamas.
Located on New Providence Island, this 4.5-star rated experience allows up to 25 travelers to enjoy a scenic boat ride, access to the pig beach’s pool and recreational areas, and a BBQ lunch.
While the experience is generally positive, with reviews praising the beautiful views and friendly staff, some have noted issues with limited food options, additional costs for drinks, and disorganized return trips.
Read our full review: Suncay Swimming Pigs Adventure With Lunch at Pigs Beach Review
Book now: Check availability
Nas: 3 Islands, Snorkeling, Pig Beach , Turtles & Lunch Boat Trip
Nas: 3 Islands, Snorkeling, Pig Beach, Turtles & Lunch Boat Trip offers visitors a comprehensive half-day adventure exploring the beautiful islands and marine life of the Bahamas.
The tour includes stops for swimming, snorkeling, and sunbathing, with the opportunity to see sea turtles and stingrays. The highlight is the visit to the famous swimming pigs of Rose Island.
With a small group size, travelers receive personalized attention from the guides. The tour includes bottled water, lunch, soda/pop, and signature rum punch.
While not wheelchair accessible, the tour is suitable for most travelers, except those with back problems, pregnant women, or serious medical conditions.
Priced from $175 per person, the tour offers a great value for the experiences provided.
Read our full review: Nas: 3 Islands, Snorkeling, Pig Beach , Turtles & Lunch Boat Trip Review
Book now: Check availability
Perfect Day – Swimming Pigs, Snorkel & Lunch
Offering an unparalleled day of adventure and exploration, the “Perfect Day – Swimming Pigs, Snorkel & Lunch” excursion transports visitors to the stunning islands surrounding New Providence.
With a maximum group size of 50, this highly-rated activity boasts a 94% recommendation rate and a Badge of Excellence. Guests can expect a full day of activities, including swimming with pigs, snorkeling, and enjoying a delicious lunch of grilled burgers, hot dogs, and unlimited rum punch.
The friendly crew ensures a safe and organized experience, making it suitable for all ages. At just $152.15 per person, this excursion provides incredible value and an unforgettable experience in the Bahamas.
Read our full review: Perfect Day – Swimming Pigs, Snorkel & Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Half Day Swimming Pigs on Rose Island, Snorkeling and Lunch
Exploring the picturesque Rose Island, this half-day excursion immerses participants in the natural splendor of the Bahamas.
With a 98% recommendation rate and a Badge of Excellence, this tour offers a unique opportunity to swim with the famous Bahamian “swimming pigs.”
Along with snorkeling, guests can enjoy a delightful lunch at the beach bar, accompanied by local beer and canned mojitos for those 18 and over.
The tour includes all necessary equipment, from snorkel gear to bottled water and soda.
With a maximum of 25 travelers, the experience ensures a personalized and exclusive adventure.
Catering to various fitness levels, this tour provides an unforgettable day in the Bahamas.
Read our full review: Half Day Swimming Pigs on Rose Island, Snorkeling and Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Harbour Island Swimming Pigs and Beaches Boat Tour With Lunch
This Harbour Island Swimming Pigs and Beaches Boat Tour with Lunch takes visitors on an unforgettable day-long adventure across the picturesque waters surrounding New Providence Island.
Starting at 7:30 AM, the tour accommodates up to 28 travelers and includes breakfast, lunch, alcoholic beverages, and the use of snorkeling equipment.
After a private boat transfer from the designated meeting point, guests will have the opportunity to interact with the famous swimming pigs on Rose Island and explore the stunning beaches.
With positive reviews from previous participants, this tour is a must-do activity for anyone visiting the Bahamas.
Read our full review: Harbour Island Swimming Pigs and Beaches Boat Tour With Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Suncay Sunken Sculpture Snorkel & Iguana Encounter With Lunch
The SunCay Sunken Sculpture Snorkel & Iguana Encounter with Lunch provides visitors to New Providence Island an opportunity to enjoy the natural beauty and cultural experiences the Bahamas has to offer.
Travelers can enjoy a boat transfer to the private Sun Cay Island, where they’ll access underwater sculptures, interact with iguanas, and indulge in a traditional Bahamian lunch.
While the experience receives mostly positive reviews, some note room for improvement in the snorkeling activity and island cleanliness.
With a duration of 20-30 minutes and a maximum of 50 travelers, this excursion offers a chance to explore the island’s unique attractions at a reasonable price.
Read our full review: Suncay Sunken Sculpture Snorkel & Iguana Encounter With Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Suncay SNUBA Diving Adventure With Lunch
Visitors to New Providence Island can embark on the captivating SunCay SNUBA Diving Adventure with Lunch, offering a unique opportunity to explore the island’s underwater wonders.
The tour includes snuba and snorkeling gear, access to the Underwater Sculpture Garden and Reef, and a scenic boat transfer to the private Sun Cay islands.
Travelers can enjoy amenities such as three beaches, two pools, and four bars, as well as a Bahamian-style lunch featuring BBQ chicken, fish fingers, coleslaw, and peas n’ rice.
While the tour receives positive reviews for its thrilling underwater experience, some guests have noted issues with the check-in process, suggesting room for improvement in organization and staff training.
Read our full review: Suncay SNUBA Diving Adventure With Lunch Review
Book now: Check availability
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Best Lunch Spots on New Providence Island?
The best lunch spots on New Providence Island offer a diverse range of cuisines, from local Bahamian dishes to international fare. Visitors can find top-notch restaurants, charming cafes, and beachside eateries that cater to a variety of tastes and budgets.
How to Get to the Top Lunch Destinations in the Bahamas?
To get to the top lunch spots in the Bahamas, consider taking taxis or using rideshare services. Many restaurants offer free parking or have nearby parking options. Travel time will depend on your starting location and traffic conditions.
What Are the Unique Dining Experiences Offered on the Islands?
The islands offer unique dining experiences, from beachfront restaurants serving fresh seafood to hidden local spots featuring Bahamian cuisine. Visitors can enjoy vibrant atmospheres, stunning views, and a taste of the island’s culture and flavors.
Are There Any Vegetarian or Vegan Lunch Options Available?
There are several vegetarian and vegan lunch options available on the islands. Many local restaurants offer plant-based dishes, and some establishments specialize in healthy, meatless fare for visitors seeking those types of dining experiences.
Do the Lunch Tours Include Transportation to and From the Restaurants?
Many lunch tours include transportation to and from the participating restaurants. This can be a convenient way to explore a city’s dining options without having to worry about getting to each location on your own.
The Sum Up
Visitors to New Providence Island in the Bahamas can enjoy a variety of exciting lunch experiences. These range from swimming with pigs and snorkeling reefs to exploring islands and encountering wildlife. With so many options, travelers can find the perfect tour to match their interests and make the most of their time in this tropical paradise.