St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

St. Augustine’s dark history comes alive on the "True Crime Guided Pub Crawl." This 2-hour experience takes participants through the city’s historic bars as they uncover captivating tales of unsolved crimes, kidnapped priests, and notorious serial killers. Sip on locally brewed beverages while exploring the haunting past that lurks beneath St. Augustine’s charming facade. With limited spots available for those 21 and over, this chilling tour promises an unforgettable outing. But what gruesome details await those brave enough to embark on this journey through the city’s shady underworld?

This experience made our list of the 3 Best Guided Tours In St Augustine Florida.

Key Points

• This 2-hour guided tour takes participants on a journey through St. Augustine’s dark history, exploring unsolved crimes and gruesome murders while visiting historic local bars.
• The tour includes stops at bars like Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila and Prohibition Kitchen, where participants can sip on locally brewed drinks while hearing chilling tales.
• The tour’s itinerary covers 0.9 miles and features stories of kidnapped priests, serial killers, and other unsolved cases that have captivated the local community.
• The tour is limited to 9 participants and is only suitable for individuals 21 and older, with a valid ID required.
• While the tour has received mixed reviews, it offers a unique opportunity to explore St. Augustine’s dark past and take in the city’s captivating true crime narratives.

You can check if your dates are available here:

Overview of the Pub Crawl

The St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl offers a unique experience for visitors. Priced from £26.17 per person, the 2-hour tour has a group size limited to 9 participants and is conducted in English.

The tour allows you to sip on locally brewed beverages while hearing tales of kidnapped priests and serial killers as you explore the city’s dark history. Highlights include visiting historic bars like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, and learning about unsolved crimes and gruesome murders.

The tour starts at Pizalleys Chianti Room and ends at Prohibition Kitchen. Participants must be 21 or older, and the tour takes place rain or shine.

Experience Highlights

Sipping locally brewed beer or other beverages in cozy pubs sets the tone for this true crime-themed guided tour of St. Augustine.

As you explore the city’s dark history, you’ll hear tales of kidnapped priests and serial killers. The tour takes you through St. Augustine’s historic art district, visiting bars like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila.

At each stop, your guide will explore unsolved crimes and gruesome murders, transporting you back in time to the scenes of these chilling events.

Itinerary Details

The tour commences at Pizalleys Chianti Room, where participants gather to discuss the exploits of serial killer William Darrell Lindsey.

Next, the group heads to Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila to learn about the murder of Father Rene Robert.

The itinerary then takes them to Forgotten Tonic, where a historical murder from 1800 on Aviles Street is recounted.

The tour concludes at Prohibition Kitchen, where the group discusses the unsolved murder of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney and the case of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley while enjoying final drinks.

Important Information

Several key pieces of information should be noted about the St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl. The tour is not suitable for those under 21 years old, and participants should bring a valid form of ID. Video recording is not allowed during the tour. The walking distance is 0.9 miles, and the tour takes place rain or shine.

Information	Details
Age Restriction	Not suitable for people under 21 years
What to Bring	Passport or ID card, driver’s license
Not Allowed	Video recording
Distance	The walk is 0.9 miles
Weather Policy	Tour takes place rain or shine

More Great Thing To Do Nearby

Customer Feedback

Customers have provided mixed reviews of the St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl. While some found the experience enjoyable, others expressed disappointment.

Common complaints include:

• Unorganized nature of the tour, with long waits for drinks at the bars
• Stories and information that were unrelated to the bars being visited
• Bars being closed during the tour, leading to early exits for some participants

Plus, some travelers have reported difficulties in obtaining refunds after booking errors.

Sip on Locally Brewed Beverages

One of the main highlights of the St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl is the opportunity to sip on locally brewed beer or other beverages in cozy pubs.

As participants explore the city’s dark history, they can enjoy the ambiance and flavors of historic bars like Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila and Prohibition Kitchen.

These establishments not only provide a refreshing respite but also set the stage for the tour’s chilling tales of kidnapped priests, serial killers, and unsolved crimes.

The combination of intriguing narratives and locally sourced libations creates a unique and immersive experience for true crime enthusiasts seeking to uncover the shadows of St. Augustine’s past.

Explore St. Augustine’s Dark History

The St. Augustine True Crime Guided Pub Crawl takes participants on a journey through the city’s dark history.

As you sip drinks in cozy pubs, you’ll hear tales of:

• Kidnapped priests
• Serial killers
• Gruesome murders

The tour explores unsolved crimes and the disturbing stories behind them.

You’ll visit historic bars like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, learning about Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney’s unsolved murder and the case of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley.

The tour culminates at Prohibition Kitchen, where you’ll enjoy final drinks and more chilling tales from St. Augustine’s past.

Unsolved Crimes and Gruesome Murders

Two unsolved crimes highlighted on the St. Augustine True Crime Guided Pub Crawl include the murder of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney and the case of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley.

Delaney’s killing in 1881 remains a mystery, with no suspects or motives ever identified. Lindsley, a local activist, was brutally murdered in 1974, but her killer was never found.

These chilling tales of unresolved violence contribute to St. Augustine’s reputation as a city haunted by its dark past. As participants sip drinks in historic bars, the tour guide shares grim details of these and other unsolved crimes that have captivated the community for generations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Tour Suitable for People With Mobility Issues?

No, the tour may not be suitable for people with mobility issues. The itinerary covers 0.9 miles of walking, which could be challenging for those with limited mobility. Participants should have good physical fitness to fully enjoy the experience.

Do the Tour Guides Provide Any Food Besides Drinks?

The tour guides do not provide any food besides drinks. The itinerary is focused on visiting historic bars and learning about the city’s dark history through guided storytelling. The experience is centered around sipping beverages while exploring unsolved crimes and gruesome murders.

Can Participants Bring Their Own Alcoholic Beverages?

Participants cannot bring their own alcoholic beverages on the tour. The experience focuses on sampling locally brewed beer and other beverages at the historic bars and pubs visited during the guided pub crawl.

Is the Tour Appropriate for Families With Children?

The tour is not recommended for families with children, as it focuses on discussing crimes and murders and requires participants to be at least 21 years old. The content and environment may not be suitable for younger audiences.

Are There Any Opportunities for Photos During the Tour?

The tour allows limited opportunities for photos during the stops, as it focuses on sharing stories about the area’s dark history rather than sightseeing. However, participants can take photos outside the venues between stops.

Recap

Embark on this chilling pub crawl to uncover St. Augustine’s dark past. Sip locally brewed drinks as you explore the city’s haunting history, from unsolved crimes to notorious serial killers. With captivating tales and a cozy atmosphere, this unique experience offers a thrilling glimpse into the true crime that has shaped this ancient city.

You can check if your dates are available here: